Two Concepts of Liberty

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Two Concepts of Liberty was the inaugural lecture delivered by Isaiah Berlin before the University of Oxford on October 31, 1958. It was subsequently published as a 57-page pamphlet by Oxford at the Clarendon Press. It also appears in the collection of Berlin's papers entitled Four Essays on Liberty (1969) and was more recently reissued in a collection entitled simply Liberty (2002).

Berlin distinguished between two forms or concepts of liberty - negative liberty and positive liberty - and argued that the latter concept has often been used to cover up abuse - leading to the curtailment of people's negative liberties "for their own good".

Berlin believed that positive liberty nearly always gave rise the abuse of power. For when a political leadership believes that they hold they philosophical key to a better future, this sublime end can be used to justify drastic and brutal means. Berlin saw the vanguard elite of the Soivet Union as a prime example of the dangers of 'positive liberty' and the concept can be seen as especially salient during the Cold War, where revolutionary sentiment was rife.

Berlin believed that a more precautious principle was needed, and that was 'negative liberty', where individuals are protected against radical or revolutionary messages, and thus have little grand or existential freedom but are granted the more 'internal' liberty to pursue recreational and consumer interests. The "for their own good" sentiment.

[edit] Criticism

Adam Curtis has illustrated what he believes are the paradoxical results of Berlin's distinction. Firstly, it has produced a peculiar, unfufilling form of 'liberty' in a world governed by numbers; what he calls 'the lonely robot', which has similarities to Nietzche's 'Last Man'. Secondly, Curtis revealed the violent and coersive means employed by the government of the United States (associated with the neo-conservative movement) to implement this 'negative liberty' around the world; what he calls 'We will force you to be free'. This critique was narrated in his three part BBC documentary, 'The Trap: What Happened to Our Dream of Freedom?'