Perfectionism

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

See also: Perfectionism (psychology) and Perfectionist movement

Perfectionism is a principle in ethics and value theory. Thomas Hurka, in Perfectionism, describes it as follows:

This moral theory starts from an account of the good life, or the intrinsically desirable life. And it characterizes this life in a distinctive way. Certain properties, it says, constitute human nature or are definitive of humanity—they make humans human. The good life, it then says, develops these properties to a high degree or realizes what is central to human nature. Different versions of the theory may disagree about what the relevant properties are and so disagree about the content of the good life. But they share the foundational idea that what is good, ultimately, is the development of human nature.^{[citation needed]}

Perfection, in this sense, is a goal to which one strives, even though the goal may be impossible to realize; the striving itself may be part of the good.

1 History
2 Perfection versus happiness
3 Perfectionism & Transhumanism
4 References
5 See also

[edit] History

Perfectionism, as a moral theory, has a long history and has been addressed by influential philosophers. Aristotle stated his conception of the good life (eudaimonia). He taught that politics and political structures should promote the good life among individuals; because the polis can best promote the good life, it should be adopted over other forms of social organization. Friedrich Nietzsche wrote that the individual reaches perfection by exercising the will to power.

[edit] Perfection versus happiness

Perfection means more than happiness or pleasure, and can be very distinct from utilitarianism or hedonism. A society geared along perfectionist principles may not produce happy citizens, far from it. Alfred Naquet remarked in L'Anarchie et le Collectivisms:

The true rôle of collective existence ... is to learn, to discover, to know. Eating, drinking, sleeping, living, in a word, is a mere accessory. In this respect, we are not distinguished from the brute. Knowledge is the goal. If I were condemned to choose between a humanity materially happy, glutted after the manner of a flock of sheep in a field, and a humanity existing in misery, but from which emanated, here and there, some eternal truth, it is on the latter my choice would fall.^{[citation needed]}

John Stuart Mill's utilitarianism is a form of perfectionism that ranks certain kinds of happiness as being more virtuous than others, and has its own definition of the good life.

[edit] Perfectionism & Transhumanism

Mark Alan Walker argues that rational perfectionism is or should be the ethical imperative behind transhumanism in his essay Absolute Versus Human Perfectionism.

[edit] References

Hurka, Thomas (1993). Perfectionism. Oxford University Press, pg. 3
Naquet, Aflred (1904). L'Anarchie et le Collectivisme.
Walker, Mark Alan (2001). Human Versus Absolute Perfectionism.
Adderholt-Elliot, Miriam (1999). "Perfectionism: What's So Bad About Being Too Good?" Free Spirit Press.
Antony, Martin and Richard Swinson (1998). "When Perfect Isn't Good Enough". New Harbinger Publications.
The 3 P's: Perfectionism, Procrastination, Paralysis